GamJams Tech: Jim McNeely's Giant TCR 2
(ed note: Normally I write GamJams tech myself, based loosely on some commentary provided to me by the bikes' owners, my inherent knowledge of bicycle componentry, and fiction artistic license. This week is different. I asked Jim McNeely, AKA The Unholy Rouleur, to give me the skinny on why he rides what he rides. My thinking is that there are some big guys out there who might leapfrog some poor equipment choices because of Jim's wisdom and experience. Jim didn't send me some crib notes or bullet points. He sent me what comes out when The Unholy Rouleur sits down to write - narratives made epic not by length alone, but from the soul breathed into them. Now I could go ahead and edit it. And as a Cat 3 with a functional threshold power that looks more like a respectable bowling score than a testament of formidable power, I could get on the phone with Fabian Cancellara and give him some Time Trialing pointers. Both seem an egregious waste of time. So here's Jim's bike, in Jim's words.)
Jim McNeely's Giant TCR 2
Mike thought some of you would find my gear choices interesting. I'm a big boy who rides okay for a middle aged beginner with a classic linebacker's build. I am 5'11", around 250 pounds in the best form I've achieved so far (last year in 'cross season), 10 pounds up on that right now and hoping to get down into the low 230 range prior to cross season. My athletic background includes nearly two decades of playing rugby and powerlifting. I'm not Bryan Vaughn strong but for power training phreaks , I was throwing CP 20 of 370 watts last year with typical 5 second power a shade under 1600. I break things.
Bike - Giant TCR 2, carbon fiber. I bought this after busting my aluminum Giant OCR's frame at the Baker Park Crit in a high speed crash. I'd heard a lot of stuff about how big guys shouldn't ride carbon, but I've found that to be crap, taking the plunge after Jon Seibold of Family Bikes in Crofton convinced me that the TCR could take it. I have around 8,000 hard miles on the OCR and it's holding up well. The advantage of carbon is it's easier on my 40 year-old back; in spite of the aggressive position it is more comfortable over a long day than more upright bikes. The carbon frame also has a little flex, and wheels seem to hold up better, though I'm not thrilled with the bottom bracket shell flexing when I sprint or really mash hard on hills. If I stay Giant the next bike will be the TCR Team, with the reinforced Ulrich bottom bracket shell. The bike handles perfectly - it is responsive without being twitchy, planted without being sluggish.
Rear wheel - Powertap Pro 32 hole, on a Velocity Deep Vee. The 'Vee is the gold standard for durable road wheels - and I've destroyed supposedly bulletproof Open Pros and the like. I went with the PT Pro because 150 grams of rotating weight close to the axis is kind of irrelevant for somebody my size.... I have roughly 10 hours a week to train and can't afford to be inefficient in my training, so it's me, Powertap, and Hunter Allen. Gatorskin tires for general riding, training or racing; Vredestein Fortezzas for serious racing. The Gators' are very long lasting and offer good traction except in the wet, and the Vredesteins offer exceptional ride quality.
Front wheel - Velocity Fusion, Ultegra hub. Matches the Deep Vee for appearance pretty much. It's as strong as I need a front wheel to be, aero, and a bit lighter than the Deep Vee.
Brakes - Shimano 105. They came with the bike and frankly the 2006 105 brakes stop better than the 2005 Ultegra brakes on my other bike. I've done "stoppies" inadvertently.
Drivetrain & STI's - Ultegra. Ultegra is a little heavier than Dura Ace, but it's pretty stout, and I can't tell the difference in shifting except on the front derailer, and I don't much like to ride in races where the small ring is going to be needed. A man's gotta know his own limitations. Ultegra chain.
Cranks - Ultegra. This is the tough choice for me. I've shredded square taper Truvativ cranks at the bottom bracket, and busted the big rings on a Truvativ Rouleur and a Race Face Roadrace crankset. After getting shrapnel in my leg from the Truvativ, I went with the Ultegra on the advice of Coppi prez Art Mitchell, who has similar ring-bending problems with everything up to and including Dura Ace. I haven't regretted the choice, it's held up fine. Jon scared me up an FSA big ring that looks like a track ring and we salvaged the Truvativ crankset, but I am always a little apprehensive when sprinting on it. Race Face? They weren't responsive to my attempts to write them to complain, though they kindly put me on their marketing spam email list. I think I threw the crankset out in the end. They should probably stick to making mountain biking clothing.
Seat - stock carbon fiber seatpost, Fi Zik Arione. I do really badly on traditional-shaped "pan" type saddles, but longer saddles that are "crowned" just disappear, and the Arione is perfect for me. The best part about the Arione is I busted the first one and they replaced it under warranty. This one is now 2 years old and going strong. Word of warning - you'll either love or hate this saddle, there's no middle ground.
Stem/Bar - Easton EA 50. I'm not thrilled with this stem; I can loosen the bars when sprinting or bunny hopping downed riders. I'm switching over to an FSA Wing Pro (aluminum) in a week or so. I'll look for a four bolt stem when I get a bike fit. My other bike has an Easton EA 70 Wing, the aluminum model. That is a great handlebar. I'm not a carbon bar kind of guy.
Bling - Serfas carbon bottle cages. Every other upgrade to this bike was a utility purchase, and I thought these were just luxury items. Then I put them on and realized they work really, really well, better than standard cages. Plus they're lighter than air.
Toolkit: This matters because I break stuff regularly on rides. Tube (in a sock, to prevent rubbing/puncture); Microflate head with two 16 gram threaded CO2 cartridges - small and efficient; Spin Doctor multitool with chain breaker which saves me every three months; Park spoke wrench (you know why); valve extender; stamped metal 4 way wrench; Skabs (not shown); Performance Hurricane HP Micro - a *great* multistage pump, actually reliably gets you to high pressure in 30 strokes or so; and a Soma steel core tire iron, because a steel core tire iron won't shatter in the cold and leave you stranded with a tight, flat Gatorskin stuck on a tight Deep Vee 5 miles from home on a 20 degree day when you're sweating and hypothermic. Don't ask.
Philosophy: A brief aside so you get my perspective. As a young soldier going on deployments I carried some blingy expensive tactical knives at first - muy macho, plus you need a sharp knife all the time camping. I also carried a little cheap jackknife I'd picked up in the military clothing sales store as an afterthought. Yet over and over again I found myself using that simple stainless $5 Army issue engineer's knife with a blade, screwdriver and marlin spike, and leaving the marquis brand knives packed away. No bling, just a big sack full of Git 'er Done! I pay for my own gear and look at a race bike the same way. I adore this bike but it's a racing and training bike, a utility vehicle, a racing tool. When it breaks in a crash, or wears out, I wont cry but will buy a new one, no big deal. The running gear is either stock kit that has proved reliable (stem excluded, and it's going soon) or aftermarket kit that has held up to a beating, and it's good enough. Could I bling up with some SRAM or Dura Ace? Sure, but would it make the bike run better? Probably not enough for me to notice, and it would cost twice as much to replace when the inevitable happens. Some day, I'll have a nice Independent Fabrication and I maybe will bling that bike out. But not this bike, it's a high utility knife, all function, which is how I like it.














Recent Comments